By: Adam C. Abrahms
Last week Assembly Bill 889 cleared a California State Senate Committee, advancing it one step closer to becoming state law. The bill, authored by Assemblyman Tom Ammiano (D – San Francisco), seeks to extend most of California’s strict wage and hour regulations to domestic employees working in private homes. While the bill excludes babysitters under the age of 18, it extends California wage and hour protections to babysitters over the age of 18 as well as any other housekeeper, nanny, caregiver or other domestic worker.
Should the bill become law individual ...
Two recent decisions involving Netflix again raise the question of whether all online business activities are covered by the public accommodation requirements of Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA") or whether a "bricks and mortar" presence is required to invoke ADA protections. In late June, in National Association of the Deaf v. Netflix, Judge Ponson of the U.S. District Court in Massachusetts denied Netflix's motion for judgment on the pleadings that challenged the application of the ADA to its video streaming website. The court found ...
by William J. Milani, Susan Gross Sholinsky, Dean L. Silverberg, Steven M. Swirsky, and Jennifer A. Goldman
In a move that signals a trend to employers, the Acting General Counsel ("AGC") of the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB" or "Board") recently claimed in two unrelated cases that allegedly overly broad "employment-at-will" disclaimers contained in employee handbooks have the effect of chilling or interfering with employees' exercise of their right under the National Labor Relations Act ("Act") to engage in protected concerted activity. As we previously discussed in ...
By: Greta Ravitsky and Jordan Schwartz
On July 24, 2012, the Fifth Circuit became the first federal appellate court in over thirty years to enforce a private settlement of a wage and hour dispute arising under the Fair Labor Standards Act (“FLSA”) in Martin v. Spring Break ’83 Productions LLC.
For decades, federal courts have consistently held that FLSA wage and hour disputes may not be settled privately without approval from either the Department of Labor (“DOL”) or a federal district court. This apparently “settled” area of law was based exclusively on the Eleventh ...
By: Bill Milani, Susan Gross Sholinsky, Dean Silverberg, Steve Swirsky, and Jennifer Goldman
EBG has prepared an Act Now Advisory on the NLRB’s recent stance on employment-at-will disclaimers, which are generally incorporated in employee handbooks. Two recent claims filed before the National Labor Relations Board in Arizona alleged that language used in employers handbooks regarding at-will employment (and how that arrangement could not be changed) were overly broad and could therefore chill employees’ rights under the National Labor Relations Act.
By Eric J. Conn, Head of the OSHA Practice Group
The deadline passed last week for OSHA to appeal a recent decision by an Administrative Law Judge (āALJā) that struck down OSHAās attempt to expand its Personal Protective Equipment (āPPEā) standard by way of an enforcement memorandum that mandated oil and gas employers ensure their employees don flame retardant clothing (āFRCā) during drilling operations (OSHA's āFRC Memoā).
Ā The Judge ruled that the FRC Memo constituted āimproper rulemaking under the aegis of an enforcement standard.ā See Secāy of Labor v. Petro Hunt LLC, OSHRCJ, No. 11-0873 (June 2, 2012).Ā The Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (āReview Commissionā) also declined to independently take-up the decision for review, so the ALJās decision is now officially a Final Order of the Review Commission.
The ALJās decision represents a meaningful victory for employers as it relates to any PPE enforcement action, not just those related to FRC. The ALJ chastised OSHA for attempting to circumvent the formal notice and comment rulemaking process required by the Administrative Procedure Act (āAPAā), by issuing the FRC Memo rather than amending its regulations. Although OSHA did not appeal the Judgeās ruling, the Agency has expressed, through both words and actions, disagreement with the Judgeās ruling.
The Petro Hunt case arose out of an October 15, 2010 OSHA inspection at an oil production worksite in North Dakota, after the Sherriffās Department notified the Agency that a fire engulfed a treater shed. Following the inspection, OSHA cited the employer for allegedly failing to provide and require employees to wear FRC.
The employer contested the citation, and a hearing was held before ALJ Patrick Augustine in November 2011. In this case of first impression, the ALJ concluded that the FRC Memo did not simply interpret the standard but, rather, amounted to a new standard that should have been subject to the formal rulemaking process under the APA.
Judge Augustine reasoned that the FRC Memo transformed the PPE standard from a āperformance-basedā standard ā which grants employers reasonable discretion to assess the nature of hazards at their workplaces and select appropriate PPE to address those hazards ā into a specification standard ā in this case, an obligation to provide a specific form of PPE (flame retardant clothing), during oil and gas operations āregardless of the particular circumstances that may be present at any individual facility.ā In striking down the FRC Memo, the Judge stated:
Complainant cannot ārequireā anything more than what is authorized by the regulations. If [the Secretary of Labor] wishes to specifically require that FRC be worn in all instances at oil and gas operations, then she must report to the required notice and comment rulemaking process. Otherwise, [OSHA] must independently prove in each case that Respondent had actual notice, or that a reasonable person in Respondentās position would have recognized a hazard requiring the use of FRC.
The ALJ also rejected OSHAās argument that the Review Commission should grant deference to OSHAās interpretation in the FRC Memo, because, Judge Augustine explained, the interpretation was āunreasonable and inconsistentā with established regulations. The ALJ proceeded to vacate the citation, reasoning that OSHA failed to establish that the employer had actual notice of a need for FRC at the inspected worksite, or that a reasonable person familiar with the circumstances and industry would have recognized the existence of a flash fire hazard. To support his decision, the ALJ highlighted the following facts:
- OSHAās failure to establish that flash fires were a hazard at the worksite;
- None of the employerās employees suffered injuries due to fires in the previous two years; and
- The employer conducted a thorough hazard assessment, and reasonably concluded that engineering and administrative controls (methods of addressing hazards generally preferred over reliance on PPE), adequately addressed any potential fire hazard.
by Allen B. Roberts and Michael J. Slocum
Under a final rule (“Final Rule”) issued by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”), commercial motor carriers that own or lease a vehicle in a business affecting interstate commerce or assign employees to operate such a vehicle are impacted by Surface Transportation Assistance Act of 1982 (“STAA”) whistleblower protections available to drivers of commercial motor vehicles (including independent contractors when personally operating a commercial motor vehicle), mechanics, and freight handlers, as ...
by Barry Asen
New York management-side attorneys and their clients were surprised and chagrined when they read Bennett v. Health Management Systems, Inc., a case decided in December 2011 by the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department (“the First Department”), which sits in Manhattan. Writing for the unanimous five-judge court, Justice Rolando Acosta directed that because the New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”) explicitly provides that it should be liberally construed, summary judgment motions should only be granted in the ...
by: Lauri F. Rasnick and Margaret C. Thering*
Title VII of the Civil Rights of 1964 (“Title VII”) not only prohibits employers from discriminating against employees or prospective employees because of their religion, but it also requires employers to “reasonably accommodate” the religious practices of employees provided that such reasonable accommodations do not cause the employer “undue hardship.” According to the EEOC Compliance Manual, reasonable accommodations may include, among others, scheduling changes, voluntary shift swaps, lateral transfers, and ...
by Allen B. Roberts and Michael J. Slocum
Under a final rule (“Final Rule”) issued by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”), commercial motor carriers that own or lease a vehicle in a business affecting interstate commerce or assign employees to operate such a vehicle are impacted by Surface Transportation Assistance Act of 1982 (“STAA”) whistleblower protections available to drivers of commercial motor vehicles (including independent contractors when personally operating a commercial motor vehicle), mechanics, and freight handlers, as ...
Recent Updates
- Reasonable Accommodations and Poor Performance: Key Takeaways for Employers
- NYSDOL Releases Guidance on Trapped at Work Act
- Governor Hochul Re-Elected: How New York Employers Should Prepare as 2026 Ends
- Allegheny County Adopts Employer-Funded Paid Parental Leave Law
- When the AI Agent Goes Off-Script: The First Incident Playbook for Frontier AI