New York’s Material Transaction Disclosure Law, in effect since August 2023, requires health care entities involved in any transaction that meets the definition of a “material transaction” to provide significant information to the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) for review, and a portion of that information is made public.
Very limited guidance from the NYSDOH to date makes it difficult for clients to know whether a transaction is subject to the law, and completing the filing is labor-intensive.
Because the filing must be made at least 30 days before closing, and a delayed or incomplete submission could postpone closing, organizational leaders need to understand the law’s requirements at the outset of a deal.
Epstein Becker Green attorney Addison Hutcheson examines New York’s Material Transaction Disclosure Law, including common filing pitfalls and potential future changes.
Key Takeaways
- Material Transaction Threshold: New York’s Material Transaction Disclosure Law defines a “material transaction” as a single transaction, or a series of related transactions within a rolling 12-month period, that results in a health care entity increasing its total gross revenues in New York State by $25 million or more.
- Filing Timing and Completeness: The filing to the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) must be made at least 30 days before closing, so waiting too long to prepare it could delay closing. If a filing is deemed incomplete, the 30-day clock does not start, which could push back the closing date.
- Possible Changes Ahead: The NYSDOH has issued limited guidance, including responses to Frequently Asked Questions, regarding the Material Transaction Disclosure Law to date, but is expected to release further guidance. Governor Kathy Hochul previously pushed for amendments that would have expanded the law’s scope, but those amendments did not pass. Efforts to amend the law will likely continue.
Read more on the NYSDOH’s FAQs on the Material Transaction Disclosure Law.
Transcript
[00:00:05] Addison Hutcheson: The Department of Health Material Transactions Disclosure Law that went into effect in August 2023 requires any transaction that meets the definition of a “material transaction” to provide significant information to the Department of Health for review, and a portion of that information is made public. The law defines “material transaction” as either a single transaction or a series of related transactions within a rolling 12-month period that results in a health care entity increasing its total gross in-state New York revenues by $25 million or more.
[00:00:42] Addison Hutcheson: I think there are a few key challenges at this point. First, there's very limited guidance from the department to date, which makes it difficult for clients to know whether a transaction is subject to the law. Second, completing the actual filing is labor-intensive, as you have to provide a significant amount of documents and data regarding the health care practices involved in the transaction to the Department of Health.
[00:01:06] Addison Hutcheson: Working to compile this data and putting it in the appropriate format for disclosure can be very difficult for clients, and it's not something that you can do on short notice. So the biggest pitfalls we see are twofold. First, waiting too long to prepare the submission, as you must make the filing thirty days before closing.
[00:01:24] Addison Hutcheson: Any delays could delay closing for a client. Second, not providing all of the information that's necessary in the filing, as the department can request additional information and there's a possibility that a filing could be deemed incomplete, which would mean that your thirty-day clock didn't start and closing could be delayed.
[00:01:42] Addison Hutcheson: Practically, it's important to bring the knowledge parties for a transaction together at the outset of the deal so you can be prepared to complete the filing. Additionally, one portion of the filing is required to be public and is listed on the Department of Health website, so clients need to be prepared for this disclosure.
[00:01:59] Addison Hutcheson: Finally, all requests under the law are mandatory, and any request to keep documents confidential must comply with New York law. In the short term, we expect the Department of Health to release further guidance on the Material Transactions Law, and we work to stay up to date, including by having conversations directly with the Department of Health in order to help our clients comply with the law.
[00:02:19] Addison Hutcheson: Additionally, Governor Hochul has, in the last two years as part of the state fiscal year budget, pushed for amendments that would have expanded the Material Transactions Law, although they did not end up becoming law. We can expect these efforts to amend the law to continue, and if they are successful, it would significantly expand the scope of the law.
[00:02:38] Addison Hutcheson: For example, the recent proposed amendment would have granted DOH the right to request a more comprehensive cost and market impact review for certain transactions after the initial 30-day review that could last up to a 180 days, and it would also create an additional 5-year post-closing reporting obligation for any transactions that fall under the law.
In Case You Missed It
CMS Finalizes Mandatory Provider-Based Attestation Requirements for Off-Campus Outpatient Departments, Epstein Becker Green Insight
FDA Finalizes Key Parts of Its NDIN Guidance Related to Identity and Safety Information: What Dietary Supplement Companies Should Know, Health Law Advisor
The Structural Pressures Behind Senior Living and Long-Term Care Distress, Health Law Advisor
About Thought Leaders in Health Law
The Thought Leaders in Health Law® video series tracks the latest trends in multiple areas of the health care and life sciences industries, featuring attorneys and advisors from Epstein Becker Green and EBG Advisors. Part of the Epstein Becker Green Insights Network.